On This Page
You offered $525,000.
Seller accepted.
Then the appraisal comes back:
$500,000.
Nobody enjoys that phone call.
But a low appraisal does not automatically mean the deal is dead.
It means the financing math may have changed.
WHY DOES THE LENDER CARE?
The lender is evaluating the property as collateral for the loan.
Your willingness to pay $525,000 does not necessarily mean the lender will base its loan amount on that price.
CAN THE SELLER LOWER THE PRICE?
Yes, if seller agrees.
Seller may decide:
Keeping the transaction is worth adjusting.
CAN THE BUYER PAY THE DIFFERENCE?
Possibly.
Depending on contract and finances, the buyer may contribute additional cash.
But Lisa does not want you automatically reaching into your savings before evaluating whether doing so makes sense.
CAN YOU SPLIT THE DIFFERENCE?
Yes, parties can negotiate when the contract allows.
Example:
- Contract: $525,000
- Appraisal: $500,000
- New negotiated price: $512,500
Buyer covers part of the gap.
Seller absorbs part.
That is one possible structure.
CAN THE APPRAISAL BE CHALLENGED?
If there is a legitimate basis, the lender may have a reconsideration process.
Lisa can review:
- Property details
- Comparable sales
- Potential factual inaccuracies
- Relevant market evidence
The argument should not be:
“We don't like the number.”
It should be:
“Here is objective information the appraisal may not have considered accurately.”
See what a comparative market analysis is for the comparable-sales picture.
WHAT IS AN APPRAISAL GAP?
In a competitive offer, some buyers agree in advance to cover a specified difference between appraised value and contract price.
This can strengthen an offer.
It can also create substantial cash risk.
Understand exactly what you're promising.
Use the appraisal gap guide before you agree to the term.
DO NOT TAKE A LOW APPRAISAL PERSONALLY
The appraiser did not insult the house.
The seller did not automatically overprice it.
Real estate valuation involves professional judgment and market data.
Lisa's job is to help negotiate the result.
